Which is Better? Saltwater Pool vs Chlorine Pool

Swimming is an exercise that leaves you both stretched and refreshed. No wonder, having a pool is considered a worthy investment for pool owners.

However, to get the best out of your pool, it needs purification. There are different types of purification options. This article will be comparing the saltwater pool and chlorine pools based on their purification methods.

Saltwater Pool versus Chlorine Pool

What is a Saltwater Pool?

Don't get carried away by the name saltwater. Saltwater pools do not necessarily taste salty. Rather, salt water is a term used to explain the major item needed to purify the pool which is salt.

To achieve a saltwater pool, you'll need what is called a chlorinator and bags of salt. The idea is to use the chlorinator to convert the bags of salt into chlorine through a process called electrolysis. What the chlorinator does is carry out filtration so that the salt can be converted to chlorine forms while releasing hydrogen as a by-product.

What are Chlorine Pools?

Saltwater Pool versus Chlorine Pool

Traditional pools on the other hand don't need to use salt as a method of purification. Chlorine is the major item needed to purify traditional pools. The idea behind chlorine pools is to use a measured amount of chlorine and other minor chemicals to disinfect the pool. These types of pools are common because they are easier and cheaper to install and maintain.

Which is Better: Saltwater Pool or a Chlorine pool?

Determining which is better is dependent on your preferences. However, comparing the pros and cons of each pool type can help simplify the decision-making process.

Benefits of Chlorine Pools

1. Cheaper to install

One major reason why chlorine pools have been popular and still in high demand is the comparatively cheap installation cost. With a chlorine pool, you wouldn't need to purchase any chlorinator or generate your chlorine.

2. Cheap running cost

A chlorine pool is also cheap to maintain. This is because the process of filtration is straightforward. It requires less energy and electricity to use. In the long run, the cost of running and maintaining the chlorine pool is affordable.

3. Chlorine pool is not toxic

Saltwater Pool versus Chlorine Pool

Another advantage of this type of pool is that chlorine is not necessarily toxic. It would take using large amounts of chlorine to cause any major harm. This makes chlorine safe to use.

Disadvantages of Chlorine Pools

1. Health Concerns

Some people are just allergic to chlorine and other odors produced by chemicals associated with chlorine pools.

A chlorine pool can trigger an asthma attack and other respiratory problems for people who are allergic to it. Some people, especially children might find chlorine too harsh for their skin if they stay in for too long.

2. Durability Concerns

Chlorine and other chemicals used for traditional pools can pollute and contaminate the pool. The paintings, the pump, and the pipe works needed to constantly pump water into the pool could also become rusty. Ultimately, this can shorten the lifespan of your pool.

3. Needs Routine Maintenance

Saltwater Pool versus Chlorine Pool

A chlorine pool needs regular maintenance and close monitoring. The pool PH balance has to be maintained at all times. You also need to make sure the chemicals are measured correctly to prevent a chlorine overdose.

4. Requires Storage

Chlorine and other related chemicals can't just be stored anywhere. There is a need to find their own space for them. A secured space that can't be easily assessed by children or strangers. Doing this will prevent domestic accidents from happening.

Benefits of Saltwater Pool

1. Safe to Use

Saltwater pools don't need chlorine and other chemicals naturally. Hence, it poses no serious threat to your health or environment.

Besides, the chlorine going in saltwater pools is obtained through electrolysis and this makes it perfectly safe. This is what makes the water gentle on the skin. It also makes swimming for long periods safe and refreshing. What's more, it is a better choice for children and people who spend a lot of time in the water.

2. Lasts Longer

The Chlorine generated by the filtration system of the chlorinator is strong enough to disinfect the pool. However, it doesn't last long enough to cause damage to the pipe, paints and other works. Corrosion will not easily occur when generating your chlorine from salt. Hence, it seems to have a better rating when it comes to durability.

Now that you are aware of the benefits of saltwater pools, the following are some drawbacks you may experience.

Disadvantages of Saltwater Pool

1. Costly Installation

The installation of the saltwater pool is quite expensive. This is because you will need to acquire a chlorinator to convert your salt to chlorine and also power the chlorinator.

Even though you may be able to operate the chlorinator yourself, chances are a professional will have to help with the installation.

2. Expensive to Maintain

The truth is saltwater pools undergo complex and rigorous upkeep. Yes, the routine may seem cheap; however, if damaged, you'll mostly require the help of an expert. Simply put, you cannot maintain a saltwater pool by going DIY alone. You will need paid professionals if you want your saltwater pool to last long.

3. Pool Finishing

Saltwater Pool versus Chlorine Pool

Pool finishing refers to all the special features added to your pool to make it look inviting. This may include underwater lighting, fixtures, masonry works and theatres.

Due to the nature of the installation, a saltwater pool would require that you use specific items for the finishing. This is to prevent interference with how the chlorinator functions. Locating these items may be stressful if you are not a pro and could also mean more costs.

Which is the Best For Your Pool?

Ultimately, the choice of what type of pool to go for lies with you. Nonetheless, here are some factors to consider when deciding which to go for.

  • Your budget
  • Allergic reactions
  • Kids
  • How long you love to stay in the pool

Keeping the above in mind can help you make an informed decision. Alternatively, you can seek the advice of a professional.

Atlas Pools are experts in the pool industry and can help you analyze your pool needs to suggest the best idea for you. They are also equipped with the best tools to build a saltwater pool if that is your preference. What are you waiting for? Call Atlas Pool today to get started with building the pool of your dreams!

Request A Quote Today

Request Your Quote Today

Please provide your full name.
Please provide a valid email address.
Please provide a valid phone number
Invalid Input
Please include a message
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Invalid Input